LETTER: Punishment isn’t always a deterrent


David Dabell (letters 21st Jan) seems to imply that corporal punishment acts as an effective deterrent.

I suggest that the opinion of one former prison officer (although I am sure there may be many who would agree with him) does not constitute consensus.

MORE ON THIS: Thought for the day: How did hitting our kids make us a better country?

My personal impression has always been that victims of caning were mainly repeat offenders (I was at school from 1936 to 1947).

It is also my understanding that hanging never stopped people poaching (other people, that is, not the ones who were hanged).

Bob Renshaw


WHAT DO YOU THINK? Should we bring back corporal punishment - or is it always wrong to beat people? To email your views CLICK HERE