Is this the best Nottinghamshire XI ever?

What the best ever Nottinghamshire XI is will also be the source of great debate.
Graeme Swann finished the 2007 season with 516 runs and 45 wickets, leading to his recall to the England side against Sri Lanka. (Photo by Tom Shaaw/Getty Images)Graeme Swann finished the 2007 season with 516 runs and 45 wickets, leading to his recall to the England side against Sri Lanka. (Photo by Tom Shaaw/Getty Images)
Graeme Swann finished the 2007 season with 516 runs and 45 wickets, leading to his recall to the England side against Sri Lanka. (Photo by Tom Shaaw/Getty Images)

The side’s all-time leading run scorer Tim Robinson took his turn to select his top team for the latest edition of Wisden Cricket Monthly.

Take a look at his selections and give us your verdict.

Reg Simpson – “He’d captained Notts through a tricky period and been the club’s outstanding batsman. I wish I had a pound for every person who told me he was the best player of quick bowling there’s ever been – in fact he told me that himself a few times!”

Stuart MacGill graced Notts between 2002 and 2004. Credit: TIMOTHY A. CLARY/AFP via Getty Images)Stuart MacGill graced Notts between 2002 and 2004. Credit: TIMOTHY A. CLARY/AFP via Getty Images)
Stuart MacGill graced Notts between 2002 and 2004. Credit: TIMOTHY A. CLARY/AFP via Getty Images)

Tim Robinson – “I wasn’t keen to pick myself – it was a close call with Chris Broad – but I asked a couple of lads at the club and they persuaded me.”

Derek Randall – "When it was his day, Randall was absolutely brilliant. There wasn’t a finer sight in English cricket. You were never quite sure what he was going to do or how he was going to do it, but you’d always pick him for the sheer entertainment value. And he could take any attack apart.”

Kevin Pietersen - “As an umpire, I’m lucky to have the best seat in the house and KP was one player you’d always look forward to watching. You could tell from the way he went about things and how he hit the ball that he was special.”

Clive Rice (captain) – “Clive was the one we all looked up to, and one of the biggest influences on my career. As a world-class all-rounder, if he failed with the bat he’d roll his sleeves up and come roaring in and bowl as quick as anybody.”

Kevin Pietersen made 1,275 runs with an impressive batting average of 57.95 during his first season at Notts. Credit: Mike Finn-Kelcey/ALLSPORTKevin Pietersen made 1,275 runs with an impressive batting average of 57.95 during his first season at Notts. Credit: Mike Finn-Kelcey/ALLSPORT
Kevin Pietersen made 1,275 runs with an impressive batting average of 57.95 during his first season at Notts. Credit: Mike Finn-Kelcey/ALLSPORT

Sir Garfield Sobers – “I couldn’t leave him out. Just look at the record. The sad thing was that at the time Sobers played for Notts he didn’t really have the team to support him, but he left the club with some unforgettable memories.”

Sir Richard Hadlee – “The greatest bowler I’ve come across. I used to field in the covers and it was mesmerising watching him run in and beat the batsman more times than not.”

Graeme Swann – “Swanny was a quality bowler who became a lot better while he was at Notts. He turned the ball and had good control, pace and flight.”

Bruce French – “It was like he’d been born with wicketkeeping gloves on. He such a natural and made it look so simple. And he was a far better batsman than he thought he was.”

Harold Larwood – “An icon of the game who has gone down in cricket history. He epitomises what it was to be a Nottinghamshire quick bowler.”

Stuart MacGill – “I saw quite a bit of MacGill during his three seasons with the club and he won several games for Notts off his own back. He was aggressive, confident and wore his heart on his sleeve.”​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

Related topics: