Nottingham Hospitals maternity review finds 'systemic failures' and 'bullying and toxic culture'
The inquiry into maternity care at Nottingham University Hospitals has found ‘deeply embedded systemic failings’ led to the deaths or harm of mothers and babies over a number of years.
The long-awaited report into then inquiry, chaired by senior midwife Donna Ockenden, revealed a catelogue of shocking failing by staff and leaders at Nottingham University Hospitals Trust (NUH).


Ms Ockenden said leaders knew there were serious issues in NHU’s maternity department as long ago as 2010 but failed to take action to prevent more harm and deaths.
Around 2,500 families and more than 800 members of staff contributed to the inquiry, which started in 2022.
Presenting her report, Ms Ockenden said multiple factors and failings were to blame, including failures in the monitoring of babies, poor interpretation of heart monitoring, a failure to recognise babies were in distress during labour and a failure to escalate some cases to senior doctors.
Ms Ockenden added many of the systems of oversight established for maternity care were ‘no longer fit for purpose’.
There was also a major criticism of the trust's workplace culture, which was described as ‘bullying and toxic’.
Ms Ockenden said: “Women who raised concerns about their baby’s movement or lack of growth were told they were ‘anxious’ or ‘imagining it’.
“Women who attended in early or advaned labour being turned away repeatedly by staff who should have cared.
"Women who begged repeatedly for cesarean sections being denied by staff acidly saying ‘we don’t cesarean sections for grandmothers’ distress’.
"Their baby died.”
Ms Ockenden also revealed how women described interactions in labour or ante-natal ward that she said she could ‘only characterise as cruel’ with one woman being screamed at by staff to ‘pull herself together’.
On another occasion, Ms Ockenden said a mother was told ‘you have to wait your turn, you’re not important, there’s other women here.’
The BBC reported that Ms Ockenden also said staff reported ‘a culture of organisational denial’ over years, where poor outcomes ‘were regularly dismissed as ‘known complications’.
She said: "What the evidence shows is that at Nottingham, a toxic culture was allowed to take hold and was allowed to persist.
"A small number of powerful leaders described in both family and staff testimonies as having infected the unit, creating an environment in which bullying was normalised, speaking up was dangerous and governance was shaped by self protection, rather than patient safety."
The review set out a number of actions NUH must take to ‘directly address the failings identified.
Ms Ockdenden said these actions, when implemented, will ‘drive improvement both within perinatal services at NUH and across England’.
Following the report’s publication, NUH Trust chairman Nick Carver and chief executive Anthony May issued an open letter, addressed to ‘the people and communities of Nottinghamshire’.
It said: "The publication of the independent review into maternity services in Nottingham is a watershed moment for affected families, our staff and for the communities we serve.
"We apologise unreservedly to the women and families who have suffered harm, loss, trauma or distress while receiving care in our services.
"We failed you, and on behalf of Nottingham University Hospitals Trust, we accept responsibility for our failings.
"Many families have been generous enough to meet with us, showing extraordinary courage and determination.
"We are grateful for that, and we want you to know that the publication of this report is not the end of a process.
"It is another important milestone in a journey that must continue.
"Your bravery and commitment to speaking up is helping improve maternity care.
"We want to thank Donna Ockenden for her work and for engaging with us throughout this process.
"Donna’s review has provided an opportunity to hear directly from thousands of families and staff.
"The direct feedback we have had throughout has helped us with our improvement efforts.
"As a result, whilst there is more to do, important changes have been made and we believe our services are now safer, kinder and better led.
"We recognise that trust is earned through actions, not words.
"We know, also, that families and the wider public will judge us not by what we say today, but by what we do next.
"The review makes clear that while improvements have been made, there is still more to do.
"We will take time to reflect on the report with humility, honesty and determination.
"At the same time, we will work with families on a meaningful apology because we know it is important to them that this is reflective of the findings of the review, and our commitment to lasting improvement.
"We can say with certainty that families will continue to be involved in our improvement plans because this review has proved that we can learn from them.
"We must also acknowledge our staff.
"Every day we see dedicated, compassionate professionals working tirelessly to provide the best possible care for women and families, often under extreme pressure and scrutiny.
"Whilst the publication of the report will be difficult for them too, we know they will reflect on the findings of the review and see this as an opportunity to continue our improvement journey.
"To these colleagues, we want to say that we know that we did not always provide you with the right conditions to do your jobs as you would wish and we take responsibility for that.
"At Nottingham University Hospitals, we are determined to provide maternity services that are consistently safe, compassionate, equitable and responsive.
"We want every family to have confidence in the care they receive..
"We want to reassure anyone using our services today that you will be safe in our care.”
"On behalf of the trust, we renew the commitments to transparency, openness and accountability. Most importantly, we renew our commitment to providing safe, high-quality maternity care at your hospitals."