‘Absurd’: Bulwell councillor unhappy no action will be taken against councillors accused of making inaccurate comments
The deputy leader of Nottingham City Council says it is ‘absurd’ no action has been taken against four councillors he accused of making factually inaccurate statements.
Coun Ethan Radford (Lab), who represents Bulwell, formally reported four councillors over alleged breaches of their council’s code of conduct when speaking on the topic of local government reorganisation during public meetings.
All nine councils in Nottinghamshire have been discussing and drafting plans to redraw their boundaries, under the Labour Government’s proposals for the most significant shake-up of how some councils operate in 50 years.
In September, Coun Radford sent a letter to four council councillors – Coun Sam Smith (Con), Coun Neil Clarke (Con), Coun Steve Carr (Brox Ind), and CounTeresa Cullen (Brox All) – asking that their statements be retracted and corrected.


All four councillors stood by their statements, prompting Coun Radford to formally complain to the county council’s monitoring officer.
The monitoring officer, senior solicitor Charlie Mason, has now concluded the statements made by each councillor ‘do not represent a breach of the council’s code of conduct’.
In a series of emails seen by the Local Democracy Reporting Service, the officer said: “In reaching this conclusion I note that a wide degree of tolerance must be afforded to political speech in accordance with article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights.
“Those rights include protection for incorrect but honestly made statements.
"I have found no evidence that the councillor made any statements that they believed to be false.”
Responding to the news, Coun Smith and the Nottinghamshire Conservative Group condemned what they describe as a ‘petty and desperate attempt’ to shut down debate, while Coun Cullen said: “I will not be told what to say or how to act by city councillors.
"I won’t be silenced until this sham reorganisation is stopped.”
But Coun Radford says he will now be taking the matter further, having written to the Government Minister for Local Government calling for a new framework for local elected members to better prevent inaccurate statements being made.
In the monitoring officer’s review of each individual councillor and their comments, they note that for some statements ‘may be argued not to have been accurate at the time of the speech’.
In particular, this was noted in regard to Coun Smith’s comments about the Nottingham tram network, which he described as ‘bankrupt and useless’, and Nottingham Castle, which he claimed was ‘closed’ – despite being open at the time the statement was made.
However the officer concluded: “Coun Smith’s statements regarding the financial position of the tram and the operational status of the castle may be argued not to have been accurate at the time of the speech.
“However, I also note that both statements appear to be based around genuine concerns on the recent operation of those assets and that I have found no evidence of dishonesty in relation to the relevant statements.”
Coun Radford said: “Having it confirmed what he had said could be argued not to have been accurate – but having no action taken because dishonesty could not be proven – ‘makes a mockery of standards in public office’.
“This is simply not good enough and it exposes a serious weakness in the codes of conduct councillors are expected to abide by.
“Even when toddlers are caught out lying they get a telling off, but not councillors? It’s absurd.
“I have written to the Government Minister for Local Government, as it is clear existing measures to make sure politicians tell the truth are not fit for purpose.
“Members of the public deserve greater protection from councillors playing fast and loose with the truth.”
Coun Smith emphasised the officer had rejected ‘every single’ allegation made by CounRadford, and added: “While the city council ties itself in knots over complaints that go nowhere, services are stretched, residents are paying the price, and confidence is at rock bottom.
“If Coun Radford spent half as much time improving the city council’s finances as he does firing off letters, Nottingham would be in a far better place.”