Hucknall CAMRA man fears traditional pubs are becoming 'an endangered species'

A Hucknall real ale supporter has spoken of his worries for the future of traditional pubs.

Andrew Ludlow is secretary of the Nottingham Branch of the Campaign for Real Ale (CAMRA) and says traditional pubs are becoming ‘an endangered species’.

He was speaking to the Local Democracy Reporting Service after a Nottinghamshire council agree plans to demolish a closed-down former village pub to make way for housing.

Broxtowe Council has given the green light for The Gardeners Arms in Cossall to be knocked down and be replaced with five new modern detached homes.

Andrew Ludlow fears traditional pubs are becoming an 'endangered species'. Photo: Iconic Media Groupplaceholder image
Andrew Ludlow fears traditional pubs are becoming an 'endangered species'. Photo: Iconic Media Group

Mr Ludlow fears the decision is another step along the road to the decline and potential disappearance of the traditional pub.

He said: “There’s higher energy costs, no relief on rates, minimum wage and National Insurance going up.

“They say ‘use it or lose it’ – but too often people are upset they’ve lost their community facility, but don’t realise they can only survive if they visit it on a regular basis.

"Our concern isn’t just the loss of a real ale option, but pubs are often the last community facility in an area.

Plans have been agreed to demolish the Gardeners Inn. Photo: Googleplaceholder image
Plans have been agreed to demolish the Gardeners Inn. Photo: Google

“Sadly, over recent years, any pub that has a decent car park or garden is now looked at by developers as provision for a mini housing estate – those are the ones in danger, pubs in a town centre have got a better chance of survival.”

The Cossall pub closed in 2022 and previous plans to use the site for five homes were thrown out by the authority in the December of that year.

Applicant NG9 Developments’ appeal against that decision was denied by the Government’s Planning Inspectorate in early 2024 over the potential loss of the ‘valued community facility’ not being justified, giving former patrons a chance to buy the spot.

After lobby group Friends of the Gardeners’ unsuccessful attempt at finding the money needed to buy the pub, the developer made its third attempt to knock down the pub – valued at £350,000 – for the five new homes.

This was approved by the council on December 3.

Meeting papers also highlighted that the empty pub has suffered with outbreaks of anti-social behaviour since it closed.

Over the past few years, the property has suffered vandalism to the point of ‘structural concern’ according to plans, with perpetrators ripping out the water tanks and flooding the building.

Furthermore, council papers said: “The police have been called out on many occasions due to vandalism and breaking and entry.”

But while now turning the site into housing will help eradicate anti-social behaviour on the site, it still means the loss of another traditional village pub from Nottinghamshire, something Broxtowe Council leader, Coun Radulovic (Brox All), like Mr Ludlow, is concerned about.

He said: “There are no new things on the horizon, they’re being replaced by micropubs which are privately owned, bought much cheaper, and hire their own staff.

"That’s the biggest issue.

“More and more pubs will be forced to close because they’re simply not viable and economic because of the cost pressures – not just by breweries, but by the Government and the cost of living.”

News you can trust since 1904
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice