Row deepens between Nottingham City Council’s ruling Labour group and defectors

A row between Nottingham City Council’s ruling Labour group and a band of defectors has deepened after some members were kicked off a key decision-making committee for the first time in over a decade.

The formation of the new Nottingham People’s Alliance (NPA) was announced in October last year.

Couns Kirsty L Jones, Imran Jalil, Anwar Khan, Naim Saqab Salim and Faith Gakanje-Ajala all quit Labour at the time, while the group’s sixth member, AJ Matsiko, joined the new party after resigning from Labour earlier in April.

However, following their defections, the city’s leadership reneged on a long-standing agreement allowing opposition members to sit on executive board meetings, during which key decisions are rubber-stamped by senior councillors.

The City Council's Loxley House in Nottinghamplaceholder image
The City Council's Loxley House in Nottingham

The move was criticised by the new lead opposition group, and a smaller group of opposition councillors known as the Nottingham Independents and Independent Group.

Coun Andrew Rule (Ind), who represents the Nottingham Independents and the Independent group, said the agreement helped provide an additional level of scrutiny before key decisions are made.

He said: “The leader’s decision to exclude opposition councillors from executive board meetings means for the first time in over a decade opposition parties will not be afforded the opportunity to provide public scrutiny and comment on reports presented to the board.

It was understood that because the number of opposition groups had grown, the authority believed it was essential that executive board meetings did not become unwieldy and remained focused on discharging its function.

Opposition members can also still sit on scrutiny committee meetings, during which a longer amount of time is given for debating key decisions before they are made.

But Coun Jones has now tabled a motion to be presented at full council on January 12, asking that opposition representation at executive board is reinstated.

The motion says: “Practice in the council for many years has been that the leaders of all minority political groups have the right to attend executive board meetings and to speak on all items, including those exempt from the public.

“In advance of the November 25 executive board meeting, Coun Andrew Rule was told that he no longer had speaking rights.

"Despite this, he chose to attend anyway and despite being a member of scrutiny committees and the leader of a minority political group, found himself evicted when exempt items were discussed.

“This appears prima facie to councillors’ right to access information under Section 100F Local Government Act 1972 (as amended).

“Given the timing of the change coinciding with the change of the political composition of the council, the motivation for this change indicates an unwillingness for the executive to consider contributions from the opposition when making the most significant decisions on the council.”

The deputy leader of the Labour-led council, Coun Ethan Radford, who represents Bulwell, hit back in a letter to Coun Jones, criticising her new group’s own lack of scrutiny.

He says budget papers went to a scrutiny committee on December 19 last year – however, the NPA failed to contribute to discussions.

In his letter, he said: “This function was carried out by majority group councillors and minority group – Coun Rule – but alas there was no contribution from Coun Jalil from the NPA.

“While making a contribution on the section about the feedback from the budget consultation, Coun Jalil did not ask a single question, make a single comment or offer scrutiny of any kind during this item on the budget and declined the opportunity to suggest any recommendations from the committee.

“It could be viewed that such an approach to scrutiny from the NPA runs the risk of appearing close to disingenuous when it comes to your group’s claimed desire and reverence for scrutiny.

“Could I ask that your group lives up to its bold claims by actually turning up to scrutiny meetings, scrutinising when they do turn up and overall starts doing the job of an opposition group?”

News you can trust since 1904
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice