How Nottingham is making a comeback after collapsing into bankruptcy

From the collapse of a publicly-funded energy firm and a shopping centre left in ruins, to a global pandemic and effective bankruptcy, Nottingham, the Queen city of the Midlands, was gravely sick just a few years ago.

But from talk of the demise of the crown, the city is beginning to look healthier after making what has been described as an ‘almost unimaginable’ recovery.

When David Mellen became the leader of Nottingham City Council in 2019, no one could have quite predicted the scale of the challenge that lay ahead.

Indeed, the authority was already in serious distress.

Coun David Mellen was council leader at a time when the authority was being hit by problems from all sides. Photo: Submittedplaceholder image
Coun David Mellen was council leader at a time when the authority was being hit by problems from all sides. Photo: Submitted

Under its previous leader of 16 years, Jon Collins, what started out as a way to create an income during the tough austerity years and bring down energy bills for the city’s residents, Robin Hood Energy turned out to be a critical mistake.

Speaking to the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS) in 2024, Mr Collins admitted that, despite the intentions, in hindsight he would not have set it up.

The council-run energy firm collapsed five years after its inception in 2015, at a time of serious energy market instability.

In fact, 30 energy suppliers had gone out of business by 2021.

Couns Ethan Radford and Neghat Khan are now in charge of continuing the council;s recovery. Photo: Submittedplaceholder image
Couns Ethan Radford and Neghat Khan are now in charge of continuing the council;s recovery. Photo: Submitted

Its demise ended up costing the city’s residents tens of millions of pounds, and, with the country’s councils already reeling from years of cuts to their budgets under the Conservative Government’s austerity programme, it laid the foundations for a perilous malady.

Coun Mellen, citing the task to close Robin Hood Energy when he became leader. recalled: “The die was cast, I had my hands tied from 18 months in.”

A damning public interest report accused the council of ‘institutional blindness’ and the Government later dispatched an Improvement and Assurance Board (IAB) to oversee critical improvements at the authority.

This wasn’t the only battle the council, and the city it governed locally, would be fighting.

It would go on to fight battles on multiple fronts.

The country was plunged into lockdown in March 2020 amid the Covid pandemic, and just months later, with high street shopping already starving, retail giant intu crashed into administration.

This left the Broadmarsh Centre, which intu had been in the process of demolishing and regenerating, in the quaking hands of an already financially-strapped council.

Coun Mellen said: “Being the leader was a costly thing to do and it did affect my health.

“When I became the leader one of the first things I had to do was deal with Robin Hood Energy.

"We changed the staff, we got expert advice, and the advice was we needed to close it.

“That was difficult because a lot of political mileage we put into what was a good thing.

"It did start with good ambitions to try and reduce fuel bills in the city.

"We are seeing that now with bills going through the roof.

“And then about the same time we had the pandemic and I don’t think people realise that, as a council, we were involved.

“We had morning meetings with senior staff at one point seven days a week.

"We wanted to make sure we got as many people vaccinated as possible and we wanted to make sure people kept to the rules, even though we find now people weren’t keeping to them in Downing Street.

“Because of Covid, the people who had been given the contract to do up the Broadmarsh Centre, intu, went bust.

"That left what we see part of now – that was a disaster.”

A few years into his tenure, the Nottingham Castle Trust, which had hailed the site’s £30m revamp as a project that would make it a ‘world-class’visitor destination, also entered liquidation.

This, too, ended up in the council’s hands.

All of these events came against a backdrop of significant Government funding cuts and crises in adults and children’s social care that have been experiencing increasing demand and costs in a privatised market.

The city was being funded £100m less per year under the Conservative Government and the damage of this perfect storm would soon become apparent.

In November 2023, the city council’s then-chief finance officer issued a Section 114 notice, declaring the authority effectively bankrupt.

This came a few years after a similar legal notice was issued for the misspending of council rent payers’ money, which ended up costing some £51m to put right.

There have been consecutive years of significant cuts across youth provision, council jobs, funding for key cultural organisations, as well as street cleaning and seemingly never-ending tax hikes.

Nottingham – which is the 11th most deprived city in the country – was left rightfully angry and exhausted.

Upon the bankruptcy notice being issued, the improvement board, chaired by Sir Tony Redmond, was replaced by a team of three commissioners – experts appointed by the Government who had the power to take over from elected councillors and make critical changes where they saw fit.

The IAB was criticised for failing to bring about any real change, with Coun Mellen saying Sir Tony took the stance of telling him off, rather than offering assistance.

Commissioners arrived in February of 2024, and a few months later in May, Coun Mellen stepped down as leader.

There had been glimmers for Coun Mellen along the way, which helped provide some light in a sea of darkness.

These included the opening of the beautiful Green Heart city park, which has since won a prestigious award, and the brand new Central Library.

Nottingham Castle was also reopened and managed to meet its initial visitor number target.

Coun Mellen said: “There was a lot of pressure to sell assets.

"Should we sell the castle? No we shouldn’t, absolutely it is the jewel in the crown in the city and we are so glad we’ve gone from the trust running it to the council running it.”

“We still had things that went on.

"Old Market Square was still full of different things, the Christmas Market and the beach.

“There were a lot of things that went on during what I absolutely agree was a difficult time.”

Nottingham’s Labour Group was suffocating under the pressure of the situation, and discontent soon became clear.

Former sheriff, Coun Shuguftah Quddoos, quit the group, citing ‘devastating’ cuts as the main reason, and later went on to join the Green Party.

Infighting was such that the national party stepped in to decide who would become the city’s next leader.

Coun Neghat Khan and Coun Ethan Radford were two of the first councillors to table their bid for leader and deputy respectively, which they did as ‘a ticket together’, they told the LDRS.

The decision by Labour to impose Coun Khan following a selection process has taken time to bed-in and led to the defection of a number of former Labour councillors along the way.

In October 2025 councillors Kirsty L Jones, Imran Jalil, Anwar Khan, Naim Saqab Salim and Faith Gakanje-Ajala broke-off to form the Nottingham People’s Alliance, while a sixth councillor, AJ Matsiko, also joined the new party after resigning from the Labour group a few months prior.

Coun Neghat Khan said: “It was unfortunate that happened but we were confident where we were.

“I understand why the party did it, because obviously the group was in a difficult situation where people were pulling in different directions.”

Two years later, under the guidance of the commissioners, the council revealed its general fund debt had been reduced by 64 per cent over the last six years, from £827m in 2020 to £292m.

The corporate officer structure, including the chief executive, was completely shaken-up in a bid to improve the culture.

Also key was the appointment of Stuart Fair as the new finance chief, who managed to take a look at the finances and bring about changes that boosted council reserves – that had been drained by the likes of Robin Hood Energy – by tens of millions of pounds.

Coun Khan, who represents the Dales ward alongside Coun Mellen, said: “We knew it was going to be a big challenge.

"We knew the leadership was going to change, but the officer side had to change.

“We had a new chief executive, new finance officer, new monitoring officer, bar one the rest of the corporate directors have changed.

“Me and Ethan were born and raised here and have lived here all our lives.

"We are going to die and get buried locally.

“When people say you only do it for an election, when we came into leadership two years ago we were very clear that in the next three years we are going to get our house in order, deliver for local people, and lead.

“It’s not about what Ethan wants or what I want, it is about what is best for the city.”

Coun Radford, who represents Bulwell, said the city is beginning to see more investment, including in some service areas that experienced cuts in the past.

This £25m investment package will see more streets getting cleaned and more regularly, grants for cultural organisations handed out, free swimming for young people, and events such as bonfire night and the Riverside Festival returning.

Council tax increased by the lowest amount since 2008, too, following a better settlement from the new Labour Government.

Coun Radford said: “If you were to ask people two years ago, do you think the authority will have a £25m investment package in 2026 the answer would be no and you’d be laughed at.

“There is more yet to come.”

Coun Khan and Coun Radford said they took the view of – politely – asking the commissioners how best they could be rid of them.

The trio, each paid upwards of £1,000 in taxpayers’ cash for every day of work, admitted the cost was high, but remained adamant they would provide value for money.

The relationship between councillors and the commissioners was much-improved over the IAB, and never did they have to use their full powers, which could have seen decision-making taken out of councillors’ hands.

While their cost was criticised throughout their stay, the situation at the authority has objectively improved over the course of their tenure.

Upon departing early in 2026, they described the turnaround as ‘almost unimaginable’ in their final report.

Nonetheless, despite the recovery, the impacts of years of turmoil will likely be seen across the city for a generation.

Coun Mellen concluded: “I wouldn’t say the current position of the council is we’ve got all the money we could ever want.

"Yes, things are a lot better and much of that is to do with a different Government.

“It is also true the council has reduced our debt and also we’ve made hard decisions over many years.

“But we are not reversing all of them, maybe one or two.

"So I wouldn’t say our position is riches, and neither was it rags.

“I think Ethan and Neghat are doing a great job.

"Would it have been better for them to have been elected?

"Probably it would, because they would have the electoral mandate I had.

“But did the NEC choose the wrong people?

"No, I don’t think they did.”

News you can trust since 1904
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice