Nottingham: Firms profiting off ‘broken’ care system as city council spends £1m a week in taxpayer cash to look after vulnerable kids

Firms continue to profit off a ‘broken and unsustainable’ care system as new figures reveal Nottingham taxpayers are forking out £1m every single week on placements for the city’s most vulnerable children.

Spending on private and independent care firms hit £54.1m over the last year in Nottingham alone.

Some of the largest providers are often investment firms, or backed by offshore private equity or shareholders, and operate for a profit.

Councils across the country are being forced to spend these sums on ‘crisis’ placements offered by these firms because of a shortage of appropriate arrangements, meaning the private sector holds the monopoly on the market.

Nottingham City Council is spending £1m a week to help kids in a 'broken' care system. Photo: Googleplaceholder image
Nottingham City Council is spending £1m a week to help kids in a 'broken' care system. Photo: Google

More than 80 per cent of providers are private and have been making considerable profits from the taxpayer by offering placements for vulnerable children.

Terry Galloway, who grew up in care himself and has been campaigning for better outcomes for children and young people living in and leaving care, described the system as ‘broken and unsustainable’.

He said: “We will continue to pay the price both in human lives and public finances unless the failure starts being treated as a whole-system responsibility.

The Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS) has been tracking the costs of looked-after children in Nottingham for the last five financial years, beginning 2021/22, up to the current year of 2025-26, which comes to a close at the end of March.

Figures obtained by the LDRS covering the last five years show a clear and significant increase in taxpayer money going to private, independent external providers of care – up until recently.

A lack of places has resulted in more private sector involvement in children’s care, to the point that more than 80 per cent of all homes in England are now owned privately.

Some of these are shareholder-owned, with the biggest 15 private providers making on average 23 per cent in profit, according to the British Association of Social Workers (BASW).

Five years ago, in 2021-22, the council spent £33.476m on external providers of care, rising to £44.99m in 2022-23.

Costs then soared to £61.485m in 2023-24, and £60.2m in 2024-25.

In the current financial year, 2025-26, the council is expected to have spent £54.1m.

This equates to more than £1m every single week.

Bulwell councillor Cheryl Barnard (Lab), executive member for children, young people and education, previously told the LDRS the council was ‘at the mercy of the market’.

“She said: The cost of care in general is driven by the private market, which for the most part is a money-making market.

‘When a single placement for one child reaches £1.1m in a year, it shows just how broken and unsustainable the current system has become.”

The LDRS asked the council for its top five costliest placements over the most recent two years.

In the last financial year, 2024-25, the figures show the council spent more than £1.1m on the care of a single child, who was looked after by an external provider.

The council paid a further £855,629, £809,367, £801,445 and £768,851 for the care of four more children respectively the same year.

In the current year, which runs until the end of March, costs have reduced, with the most costly placement for one child projected to total £844,099 for the year.

Below that, £789,942, £760,820, £756,496 and £693,190 are projected to be spent on the care of four other children.

According to the FOI response, these are payments to external providers only, and do not include council overheads such as commissioning, management, IT, HR and finance.

It also excludes other costs, such as passports and birth certificates, and does not include Government funding related to the placements.

Mr Galloway grew up in the care system alongside his sister, Hazel.

They made a promise together they would change the system, but in January 2008, Hazel was murdered by her partner, leading to Mr Galloway spearheading a campaign for change in her memory.

While these children often have a significant number of needs, Mr Galloway told the LDRS: “When a single placement for one child reaches £1.1m n a year, it shows just how broken and unsustainable the current system has become.

“Local authorities are being left to carry the financial burden of a problem that should be shared across Government departments.

“Corporate parenting responsibilities will extend across departments such as the NHS, DWP, justice, prisons and Department for Culture.

“That must translate into real action.

"Those agencies should be actively engaging right now with local authorities and sitting their corporate parenting boards so that support for children in care and care leavers is coordinated properly.”

He added the lack of co-ordination is failing children and care leavers and costing the wider economy astronomical sums, while councils are forced to divert huge sums into crisis placements, leaving less funding for other services.

He said: “We are continuing to transform children’s services by strengthening early help and family support.”

The council has been undertaking a transformation programme ‘to ensure children are in the best placement for them, and at the right time with the correct support to meet their assessed needs’.

Coun Barnard continued: “We have worked with children, families and providers and, we are already seeing some progress.

“The figures show the cost of the most expensive placements and the average weekly cost have reduced compared with the previous year.

“We are continuing to transform children’s services by strengthening early help and family support, reducing the number of children coming into care where it is safe to do so, and developing more local provision so children can stay closer to their communities.

“We are also working to reduce reliance on agency staff by growing our permanent workforce.”

The National Audit Office (NAO), the UK’s independent public spending watchdog, said council spending on children in residential care pointed to ‘market failure’.

Wales this year became the first UK nation to legislate to end private profit in children’s residential and foster care.

A new law passed by the Senedd in February means care for looked-after children will only be provided by the public sector, charitable or not-for-profit organisations in the future.

In England, the Department for Education says it is ‘driving the largest ever reform of children’s social care’, which is backed by £2bn to break the cycle of crisis for children.

This includes the planned recruitment of more family help workers and new legislation aimed at ending profiteering.

Last year the Children’s Homes Association (CHA), which represents providers, said language about profiteering and ‘the market' is being used while underplaying government’s long-term neglect of residential care and Ofsted’s own part in blocking new high-quality homes.

The CHA, which does not represent offshore or private equity-owned providers, says many ‘are small, practitioner-run homes on modest margins’.

News you can trust since 1904
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice