BREAKING: Plans for 100 homes on Misk Hills approved by Government Inspector
Controversial plans to build 100 new homes on Misk Hills in Hucknall have been approved by an independent Government inspector.
And the decision has provoked fury from local green belt campaigners and councillors.
Ashfield Council turned down plans for 100 homes off Common Lane at Misk Hills in 2023 due to concerns over the impact on the greenbelt.
Aldergate Properties Ltd, the developer, resubmitted its proposals in 2024 and were again turned down.


The developers then appealed to the Government’s Planning Inspectorate over the ‘non-determination’ of the plans.
And the Inspectorate has now overturned the council’s decision meaning the houses will now be built.
It is a devastating setback for green belt campaigners and residents alike who are also fighting plans to build 3,000 new homes on Whyburn Farm.
Jemma Chambers, founder of campaign group Hucknall Against Whyburn Farm Development, called the decision ‘horiffic’ and said the developers ‘should be ashamed.
But she also pointed the finger of blame squarely at the council for its lack of a local plan that has allowed this proposal to go through.
She fumed: “I wonder why we bother with local councils when things like this happen.
"But Ashfield Council are as much to blame because we don’t have a local plan that stops things this being allowed to happen.
"They should have pulled their fingers out and get moving much more quickly.
"They destroyed the Labour plan and started again and it’s taken five years to get to this point, only for it be completely ruined by a speculative planning application, which has now been approved because there’s no local plan in place.
"Why do we bother with a consultation that does not take into account anything that the local community, who are the only ones who are going to be impacted by this, have to say?
"It’s horrific and they should be ashamed of themselves."
Ms Chambers also conceded that this decision was a worrying development in the fight to save Whyburn.
She continued: “It is a worry and it’s a blow because Misk Hills is an extension of Whyburn and everything people enjoy about that area is extended to Misk Hills.
"It’s the first hill in the Pennine chain, it’s got a World War II bunker on it, but they don’t care about that because they’re just greedy and all they care about is the next profit they can make and they should be ashamed of themselves.”
Local councillors meanwhile, have turned their ire on the Labour Government.
Coun Lee Waters (Ash Ind), who represents Hucknall Central on the council, said: “I’m furious that 100 houses on Common Lane have been forced on Hucknall against the clear wishes of local people.
“Ashfield Council refused this development, residents opposed it, yet a Government-appointed inspector has overturned that decision and imposed it anyway.
“That is not local democracy, it is Whitehall riding roughshod over our town.
"It shows real contempt for local people, local councillors and the community that has to live with the consequences.
"Labour’s build-build-build agenda is putting targets and developers first, while Hucknall is ignored. The Government owns this decision, and local people are left to pay the price again.”
Coun Dave Shaw (Ash Ind), who represents Hucknall West, said: "It beggars belief that this Government has allowed this to go ahead.
"The people of Hucknall West will not forget how they have been let down by our MP’s party.
"We still face the prospect of a massive incursion on Whyburn Farm and still no decision on it's future or the local plan.
"This Government is trying to rip the heart out Hucknall and it's countryside.
“A Government who wants to build 1.5m homes in five years – all at the cost of the living green belt.”
But Hucknall’s Labour MP Michelle Welsh (Lab) countered that the lack of a council local plan was the biggest factor.
She said: “As the Ashfield Independents have failed to put an up-to-date local plan in place, defence against speculative developments like this one is greatly undermined.
"The lack of leadership by Ashfield Independents is leaving our precious green space wide open to attack.
“I am deeply disappointed in the decision made by the independent inspector and remain furious that the failures of Ashfield Council have let Hucknall down yet again.
"I objected to this application and will continue to speak out against building on Whyburn Farm and Misk Hills.
"This week, I am holding a public meeting with residents to discuss the future of our green belt and how we can protect it.”
But Hucknall county councillor Richard Darrington (Ref) said the decision to allow the homes to be built was ‘the key to the door’ to Hucknall’s green belt for developers.
He said: “We’re being sold short by this Government, it’s simple as that
“And I don’t think there’s anything anyone can do about it, they’re just steamrollering through our countryside at a stupid rate.
"I just don’t see the purpose of it and the impact on Hucknall will be just shocking – we haven’t got the infrastructure, no two ways about it.
“It’s very frustrating.”