Nottingham: Former city council finance boss's complaint 'wasted time and money

Ross Brown, the council's former Section 151 Officer, issued the 'bankruptcy' notice in November 2023. Photo: Submittedplaceholder image
Ross Brown, the council's former Section 151 Officer, issued the 'bankruptcy' notice in November 2023. Photo: Submitted

A thrown-out complaint made by Nottingham City Council’s former finance boss against a councillor ended up costing taxpayers more than £7,000, it can be revealed.

The complaint – described as ‘a waste of council time and money’ – related to a long-standing city councillor’s attempt to publicly scrutinise the finance chief’s decision to declare the authority effectively bankrupt in November 2023.

Ross Brown, who was appointed to the position of corporate director for finance – known for legal reasons as its Section 151 officer – in December 2022, said in his opinion the council was ‘unable to meet its statutory requirement to deliver a balanced budget for 2023-24’.

While councils cannot go bankrupt in the traditional sense, the issuing of what’s known as a Section 114 notice meant all new spending had to cease because the authority was unable to set a balanced budget, as required by law.

Ross Brown, the council's former Section 151 Officer, issued the 'bankruptcy' notice in November 2023. Photo: Submittedplaceholder image
Ross Brown, the council's former Section 151 Officer, issued the 'bankruptcy' notice in November 2023. Photo: Submitted

However, some city councillors at the time attempted to scrutinise the decision, with one now suggesting ‘it was to a significant extent based on assumptions which were never thoroughly explained to elected members’.

It has also been argued the council had more money in its reserves than thought at the time.

Coun Graham Chapman (Lab), former leader and deputy leader and a former accountant, questioned the decision publicly during an extraordinary council meeting in 2023, during which members had to note Section 151 officer Mr Brown’s report.

In his speech at the time, Coun Chapman said: “We have more reserves than Middlesbrough, yet in Middlesbrough, there is no 114.

"In Bradford they are talking £70 (budget gap, we are talking £20m, yet no 114 in Bradford.

“So why no 114 in these places?

"In my view, it’s because they know what the implications are of next year’s Government settlement on the existing year, and they are waiting.

"So why us now? We’ve got to ask that question.”

Coun Chapman was interrupted by Lord Mayor, Coun Carole McCulloch (Lab), who said – on the advice of officers – the council was only present to discuss the response and not the merits of the decision to issue the Section 114 notice.

After the meeting Mr Brown made a formal, internal complaint against Coun Chapman, alleging a breach of councillors’ and co-opted members’ Code of Conduct and that his professionalism had been undermined.

An email from the council’s former monitoring officer and director of legal and governance, Malcolm Townroe, shows the complaint could not be resolved and Mark Heath at Veale Wasbrough Vizards LLP was instructed to conduct an investigation.

The complaint was not upheld, but ended up costing city taxpayers £7,500, the Local Democracy Reporting Service can reveal.

Mr Brown left the council in November 2024 and works as the corporate director for finance at the London Borough of Bexley.

He has been contacted for comment but has yet to respond.

Coun Chapman said: “It was an irresponsible complaint which should never have been made.

“I told them so at the time.

"It tried to shut down democratic challenge, which now has turned out to be totally justifiable.

“It wasted council time and money.”

Coun Andrew Rule (Ind), a member of the Nottingham Independents and Independent opposition group, said he learned of the complaint and wrote to Mr Townroe in defence of Coun Chapman.

He said previously: “While I did not agree with Coun Chapman, he absolutely has the right to raise his concerns at full council and I think it is a very slippery slope when you get to the point of officers trying to suppress debate.

In his Section 114 report Mr Brown said the council had been facing a £56.899m budget shortfall – largely due to soaring costs in people’s services such as adult social care.

While the authority managed to bring this down to £23m, Mr Brown deemed it necessary to issue the notice.

The decision resulted in the previous Conservative Government sending in a team of three commissioners to oversee critical improvements.

It comes as councillors agreed to make changes to its constitution so that each corporate director and budget holder was accountable to council at a meeting of full council on September 8.

During the meeting Coun Chapman welcomed the changes, but added there should be sanctions for officers who do not follow the constitution.

He said: “The system for holding officers to account is opaque.

A council spokesperson added: “Complaints are dealt with using the council’s existing procedure and this can involve external advice being sought where appropriate.”

News you can trust since 1904
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice